Mormegil@bookwyrm.social reviewed Piranesi by Susanna Clarke
Fun scientific paganisim?
3 stars
Content warning Discussion of plot and reveal of mystery. Don't spoil it for yourself!
I enjoyed this. It's a short read. Felt like a good mystery novel? What I mean by paganism is by the way Piranesi himself resorts to the sort of ancient state that the antagonists of the novel desire. But I feel that this 'ancient state,' of nature/environment worship is idolized (ironically). Yet even in the midst of his Pagan consciousness, Piranesi analyzes things in the scientific tradition by cataloguing the labyrinth and his journals (hence scientific paganism).
If you have learned anything about ancient history, I think it is hard to come to the conclusion that Pagan worship and rituals are the coolest thing about ancient people (child sacrifice and self mutilation guys!). This isn't really a review of the novel or the writing (which are good), but the subtext. I was not as immersed as I wanted to be. Though the House itself stuck in my mind, I wanted more from the ending. Also I might have just missed this, but is leaving the Labyrinth really as easy as walking through the door in the First Vestibule? In that case, couldn't Piranesi have left before the book even started? Anyway. I did enjoy it, but it didn't change my life. The presentation was creative.